Photos
What collectors say
All reviews on Google- 5.0
“Today, February 24, 2026, my brother and I took a box of music CD’s in to sell (approximately 60 CD’s). The owner happily greeted us upon entering the store. I put my box of CD’s on the counter for him to take a look through. I offered a variety of music genres such as country, jazz, rock, pop rock, and several soundtracks from various movies. He looked through my collection carefully and explained that what I had would be difficult to sell, as the particular CD’s I was offering aren’t big sellers at this time. A couple of the CD’s, unfortunately, didn’t have the accompanying cover sleeve, just the CD itself in the case. I had brought them in anyway just to see if there was even any interest in them. We discussed the fact that times have changed regarding listening to music, as CD’s are phasing out, much like cassette tapes have phased out completely. Nowadays , people listen to music in their vehicles through their cell phones. CD players aren’t installed in cars like they used to be. The owner (I forgot to ask for his name) wasn’t able to buy any of my CD’s, due to the fact the ones I offered aren't high in demand or are ones that collectors are currently looking for, but he did offer me to donate them if I wished. Upon thought, I decided to donate them so that I didn’t have to carry them back home and take up space again. The store offers a huge selection of vinyl albums, 45’s, movie DVD’s, and CD’s. I think the store specializes more in vintage/collectors-type albums and CD’s. The store was clean and very well-organized and maintained. Sections were alphabetically organized and labeled. My brother and I enjoyed talking with the owner. As we were leaving, he welcomed us to come back. I would definitely recommend this store, Remember When Records, for anyone looking to add to their music library or someone wanting to start their collection. This store has a lot to offer to anyone that loves and appreciates good music.”
Coral Starr · Google review
- 2.0
“I would love to look through the impressive inventory here, but I would not recommend entering unless you are willing to request only specific records with 100% intent to buy. A lot of people in the reviews state the owner is mean, and I don’t get that impression honestly. But overly intense and scary? Yeah. He was eager and talkative, but also made us feel like we couldn’t actually look at any of the merchandise. As soon as we entered, the owner told us about his organization system and stated that because everything was in such good shape, that “this isn’t a store, it’s a collection.” I assume this stated condition is the rationale for prices much higher than would be typical for both the VHS tapes and records. I picked one record up to look at the back as I was considering purchase and was immediately met with “Don’t pick it up if you’re not going to buy it! You’ll lose the place!” I smiled and said “I won’t, don’t worry!” And he said “Yes you will, how are you supposed to find it if you take it out of its spot?!” I put the record down and we left with a polite “Thank you.” We have traveled to 46 states, have an extensive vinyl collection and never experienced something quite like this where it genuinely feels like you’re not allowed to look at the merchandise. I don’t want to judge an older man who clearly has his heart in his small business too hard, but I think he would have much more success if he were more welcoming. I did read he sells on eBay which is a good venue if he doesn’t want people to touch the records. Customer service never has to be overly fluffy and the customer is not always right - but the customer isn’t supposed to be the assumed enemy either. Best wishes to him.”
Gabby Y · Google review
- 5.0
“It hurts when i read some of the reviews that are negative, because it does not portray who the owners are. People are looking for cheap products everyday, and no longer want to pay for quality. The man is a true patriot, visionary and gentleman. He does not put up with the usual entitled crap so many have accepted as normal behavior. Do you inspect a record before buying on eBay? If you have an issue with a record, go back to the store first, before leaving nasty reviews. I’ve been a customer since 2018, and I would always go to his store for my records. I visited recently and spent over 200 on my albums. By the way, I used to live in Greensboro and now drove over 7 hours to come back to the store. I wouldn’t do this if the store owners did not have integrity and honesty at the forefront of what they do. I’ve never had any issues with my albums, and the grading is spot on. By the way, they were sealed with tape, and I agree this is necessary to stop people fingerprinting his records. This is a great store, the owners are great people and I support their ideals.”
Annoch · Google review
Location
More record shops in NC
See allRecord shops
Mad Jack's Records & Comics
315 West John Street, Matthews, NC
Closed today
(704) 965-0074
Record shops
Track Record Vinyl Shop & Listening Lounge
115 North Main Street, Fuquay-Varina, NC
Open today · 11:00 AM – 5:00 PM
(919) 285-3200
Record shops
WHOA!TONE Records
105 North Main Street, Kernersville, NC
Closed today
(336) 930-0443
Record shops
Ultimix Records
3404 West Wendover Avenue, Greensboro, NC
Open today · 10:00 AM – 5:00 PM
(336) 288-7566