EventGambit

Toy shops

Lost4toys

4.9(90) Garden City South, NY

Photos

Photo: Lost4toys
Photo: Lost4toys
Photo: Lost4toys

What collectors say

All reviews on Google
  • 5.0

    “What a pleasant surprise. This store is full of great finds with a great variety of toys and collectable items. The gentlemen inside are welcoming and engaging. I admire a business where its obvious thay they love their store and take pride in their business. We'll done!”

    Oscar Montano · Google review

  • 4.0

    “First time going there yesterday with a buddy of mine 6/13/26 we got some great things yesterday. I do love the atmosphere going in there. It’s like a little sanctuary for all geeks of all generations. Got myself a few Pokémon cards. And looking forward to getting some comic books over there and maybe some more Pokémon cards in the future. If you’re a geek of pop culture, then this is your place to check it out.”

    Edwin Vasquez · Google review

  • 5.0

    “First time stopping in and place was awesome. Great selection, owner was super cool and friendly. Purchased some pokemon packs and got some awesome pulls. Go check them out highly recommend !”

    Frankie Cirasola · Google review

Location

Lost4toys
267 Nassau Boulevard
Garden City South, NY 11530
Get directions

More toy shops in NY

See all