EventGambit

Toy shops

Fantastic Toyage

4.2(175) Massapequa, NY

Photos

Photo: Noah Rosen
Photo: Noah Rosen
Photo: Justin Ting

What collectors say

All reviews on Google
  • 5.0

    “Fantastic Toyage is truly revenge of the collectibles!!! Located on Merrick rd in Massapequa, every toy enthusiast should visit this nostalgic store!!! The inventory at this place is awsome, Alex is super cool & friendly!!! I highly recommend!!!!”

    MIKEY LAP · Google review

  • 5.0

    “Visiting New York for Thanksgiving with my girlfriend. Been looking at this place for about a week. As an avid collector I can say what a piece of American history. This place was like a museum. It took us back to our childhood with what they had for sale. From Ben Cooper costumes, creepy crawlers, board games, magazines, and even buttons. It was really cool to see the vote for Nixon to Reagan buttons from the past. I'd recommend everyone to stop by and shop at this local business. Don't forget to bring cash to help them out even more. Thank you Fantastic Toyage! Will be back.”

    Adam Price · Google review

  • 1.0

    “Alex…I Hope your soul is worth the $435 you robbed me of. You accused me of being dishonest... Self project much? I want my money back for the defective Mattel Vertibird you sold to me for $435.00. I bought this to use and enjoy. I can't do either because you sold me a defective item and refuse to resolve the issue. You made me join Yelp just to tell the truth about how you operate. You tried to pass the Vertibird off as "factory sealed cherry mint". It wasn't, you know it wasn't. please do the right thing and make this right. If not...then these posts remain if you make it right, these posts will be deleted and you will be rightfully praised. Thank you. 10”

    Ed Hess · Google review

Location

Fantastic Toyage
5288 Merrick Road
Massapequa, NY 11758
Get directions

More toy shops in NY

See all