EventGambit

Toy shops

Mary Arnold Toys

4.6(218) New York, NY

About the shop

Old-school stalwart stocking a wide range of educational & imaginative toys, games, books & gifts.

Photos

Photo: Diego Lorente
Photo: Diego Lorente
Photo: Mary Arnold Toys

What collectors say

All reviews on Google
  • 5.0

    “10/10 experience the selection is wide and unique for the small space. You can find toys for all ages in there at a decent price! Plus I was being indecisive over a fidget toy and they let me open and and play with them after asking of course! They even tried it out themselves 😆 I also found some good needoh type of squishies in here got a hyland cow for 4 dollars and my fidget spinner for 8! You can beat that right now at all. My daughter got 2 sensory toys as well and she was very happy about it. Definitely recommend this shop to everyone and can't wait to come back on my next trip to the city.”

    Zoraida Rivera · Google review

  • 5.0

    “Incredible toy shop. Great service and selection. The staff all asked us if they could help us or answer any questions. Shops like this are hard to find these days.”

    Ken Weary · Google review

  • 5.0

    “Option 1 – Polished and friendly: "Wonderful variety of toys and super friendly staff! They even wrapped my gift beautifully at checkout." Option 2 – Simple and upbeat: "Awesome toy selection and really helpful employees. I loved that they offered free gift wrapping when I checked out!" Option 3 – Slightly more detailed: "Such a fun place to shop — tons of great toys to choose from, and the staff couldn’t have been kinder. The complimentary gift wrapping was a perfect touch!"”

    Alizabeth · Google review

Location

Mary Arnold Toys
1178 Lexington Avenue
New York, NY 10028
Get directions

More toy shops in NY

See all